Skip to main content

Very Bad Men

Receptionist: "How do you write women so well?"
Melvin: "I think of a man, and I take away reason and accountability."
                                                           --As Good as it Gets (1997)

When inventing a character of my own sex, I find I have limitless amounts of inspiration. As a woman, I can draw qualities from myself or from my sisters and close friends. I can reflect on other female fictional characters with whom I have felt a connection. But when it comes to creating men, I have found it involves a good deal more work. Because ultimately, they are a strange species whom I do not understand.

Creating male characters who are good guys is somewhat of a challenge, but it's the bad guys—those terrible men who make life hell for my (mostly) female protagonists that are the hardest to create. It's so easy to create that one-dimensional misogynist who gets off on causing pain and is bad just because he's always been that way. You'd be amazed (or maybe you wouldn't) how often I would hear some young lady in my undergrad literature classes calmly explaining that the male antagonist acts that way because "men are just like that."

But they're not. They're complicated, even the ones who say they are not. So how do you go about creating a male villain? First and foremost, understand that your villain, does not think he is a villain. He is a reasonable person who wants reasonable things, and its not his fault that the protagonist is getting in his way. For me, all of my primary protagonists will be women, so deciding how my male antagonist feels about women is of primary importance, as it will dictate how he interacts with my protagonist. Above all things, your villain knows that he is absolutely right. Not about everything, just about the issue that puts him at odds with your protagonist. And like it or not, when dealing with heterosexuals of the opposite sex, gender relations will come into it. Men don't treat men the same way they treat women. Ever. And women don't react to men the way they react to women. Ever. So let's look at an some example.

The video below is a segment from Richard Dawkins' The God Delusion. He is an atheist scientist who went to Jerusalem and interviewed various people from Christianity, Judaism and Islam. He does not bring up gender at all, nor cultural differences between east and west. He is there to discuss the effect of religion and why it is necessary. His interview subject knows this. But listen to his words and how quickly he jumps to the subject of women. Listen to the venom. Who is this American man and how did he become this way? Do you think when he describes himself, he says "I'm a virulent misogynist who seeks to control women above all other pursuits?" Of course he does not. Why did he choose Islam, rather than Buddhism or the Judaism he was raised with? Specifically, why did he choose radical Islam? One can imagine it was appealing to him because of the sense of superiority it gave him as a man.

This is an extreme case, of course, and I have never written about a male character like this. For a perfectly crafted example of such a character, see William Hamleigh in Ken Follett's The Pillars of the Earth. I find these men to be too easy to figure out, too easy to manipulate. Its easy to see what they want. Its easy to twist them. Flattery and submission are way past being interesting for me. So my characters are never such blatant misogynists, nor are they sadists, because in my experience, people like that are much rarer than Hollywood would have you believe.

When I created Alfredo, I decided on the qualities I had seen too many times from my former fellow Marines. He is dangerous without being psychotic. He has a God complex but is not delusional. He firmly believes in the Biblical superiority of men, but is not a misogynist. There is an order to things and in all of his actions, he genuinely believes he is working toward God's goals, which (as coincidence would have it) also happen to be his goals. My hope in creating his character was not only to allow my reader to feel what it would be like to be Alfredo, but towards the end in his scenes with Shannan, I want the reader to experience what it would be like to be at Alfredo's mercy.


  1. My brother would probably say there are only two things you need to know to understand men: sex and beer. :)

    Thanks for an insightful post, Christine. It's often been charged that men don't know how to write female characters. Your post shows its sometimes difficult to bridge the gender divide from the other side, as well.

    One of the great benefits of writings is that it encourages us to explore experiences outside of our own and to see the world through someone else's eyes, something "bad" men (and women) are usually unwilling to do.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

On Psychopaths - Part 2 of my Daredevil Review

I will start this review with a mandatory disclosure: I love me some Vinnie D. That's Vincent D'Onofrio to you normal folks. I love him in everything he has ever done. I loved him as the sweet yet prideful young man in Mystic Pizza, I loved him in his small role as "Thor" in Adventures of Babysitting, I loved him when he wore an Edgar suit in Men in Black, and I loved him the mostest in Law & Order: Criminal Intent. So while I'll be telling you the strengths and weaknesses of the show, don't be concerned when I seem to love the villain more than the hero.

Though Kingpin AKA Wilson Fisk had a small cameo in the Defenders, Season 3 of Daredevil marked his triumphant return to the status of Big Bad. And make no mistake, Wilson Fisk is as Big and Bad as they come. Obey him or he will kill you. Though he might kill you even if you do obey him. Hypothetically, he might savagely crush your head in if you are simply the bearer of bad news. Hypothetically.


On Faith - Part One of my Daredevil Review

"I would rather die as Daredevil than live as Matt Murdock."

As I mentioned in my review of Daredevil Season 2,  I love this show, so I didn't want to simply write another review. Instead, I chose to write three articles on what I saw as the three main strengths of this season: its honest depiction or faith and the struggles of mere mortals to live it; the effects of psychopathy and the morality of treating people who have it; and the ability of friendships to fill the hole left by a missing family. In my Season 2 review, I mentioned how the show's writers have stayed true to the spirit of the comic in their characters, in the actors they cast, and the direction of the plot. Season 3 begins with another strong and unapologetic nod to the original comic: its focus on Matt's faith, or in this case, his loss of it.

In the last episode of The Defenders, a building fell directly on top of Matt Murdock, AKA Daredevil, as well as Elektra, the love of his life whose sou…

Maximum Harm: The Toxic Maternal Instinct of Therapists in Daredevil and The Punisher

I have a particular interest in feminine aggression and how women's ways of destruction differ from the masculine baseline of beatings, gunfights, and demolition of infrastructure. The Netflix Marvel shows have been universally strong in depicting women as realistic, complicated, and aggressive in uniquely feminine ways.

Of course, the heroines like super-powered Jessica Jones and driven Karen Page exemplify these qualities, but so too do the female villains--the ones who know they are villains... and those who think they're on the side of the angels.

Daredevil Season 3 and The Punisher Season 2 have an important connection that struck me (other than being Marvel shows on Netflix): They both feature a female psychologist whose overabundance of care for her psychopathic patient results in great harm being wrought on the populace. I don't think it's a coincidence that there is a fair bit of overlap in the writers for these two shows (all 12 writers for Punisher also were …